HISTORICAL FICTION WEEK #2: Allow your characters to be centuries ahead of their time


‘Fire!’ shouted Edward, pointing at the bakery. ‘Hobbington, old friend, we must do something.’
‘Should I fetch buckets?’ asked the clergyman. Edward shook his head.
‘No,’ he said. ‘The pace at which that fire is spreading would make buckets useless. We ideally need a pressurised system of pipes and tubes to spray water across the building from a distance, possibly carried on some kind of large vehicle.’
‘Such a thing would take many men to operate,’ observed the Reverend Hobbington.
‘Men and women,’ said Edward. ‘There is no reason whatever that women should be considered inferior to men in carrying out physically demanding tasks or taking on other responsibilities. In fact, should we ever have a system of government which functioned purely on the basis of a popular mandate, I think that women should be given an equal say to men.’
‘My goodness,’ laughed Hobbington. ‘You do have some novel ideas, Edward.’

11 comments:

  1. Ah, you must have read World Without End recently too.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hobbington is an awesome name.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Haha. I thought of Pillars of the Earth, Karen. I'm loving Historical Fiction Week!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Heh. This is one of my pet peeves - period pieces where the heroine has exactly the same attitudes as a modern highschooler. Not to name any names *cough*Elizabeth Swan*cough*.

    ReplyDelete
  5. And while they chat, the bakery goes up in flames.

    ReplyDelete
  6. This is SO annoying to me. I have to agree with the anonymous who is sick of prematurely feminist heroines. It is far more interesting to create a character who actually manages to become heroic within the system of thought and structure of society that existed at the time.

    ReplyDelete
  7. It's also important to remember that our time is just one period in history. Attitudes will change from what they are now, too. Someday, our penchant for projecting our own attitudes on to both the past and the future (i.e. Star Trek, where everyone has the attitudes of a late 20th century NPR listener) will seem as silly and dated as those 1950s sci-fi movies in which people in the spacefaring future act exactly like 1950s Americans.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Creative anachronisms can be fun if applied with a light touch.
    Consider Steve Martin from SNL doing his Theodoric of York gag. Youtube knows about this.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Reminds me of Dr. Quinn.

    ReplyDelete
  10. If I read one more historical romance where the 18th-century midwife protagonist has an advanced knowledge of germ theory and modern obstetrics, I think I will give up historical fiction for good. That goes double if said protagonist successfully performs a Caesarian section.

    ReplyDelete